Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

That's just a random demo. It's not particularly relevant for the concept they're trying to gather feedback on



The demos should be motivating the feature. A bad demo is destructive to that effort. This is a very bad demo.


If you open the demos in a browser like Safari that doesn't support the feature, the demos remain as normal grid-aligned cells.

There I realize that masonry mainly works when your cells have such different heights that to grid-align them creates a lot of vertical dead space. Images and news blocks with images make sense for masonry for this reason and it feels good.

But text-only cells where the cell heights don't differ much, they seem better without masonry. The megamenu demo also works much better as a normal grid because they start with a header so grid alignment lets you scan the headers left to right easily.

A text-only newspaper could make sense with masonry because you aren't trying to navigate relationships between the items, and presumably the content can vary the cell height a lot.


People who have nothing to say on the shed talk about the color




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: